Afghanistan's fight against corruption received a double blow Thursday as two organisations made public statements condemning the Afghan government's use of donor funds.
At the US Congress, the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR) said Afghanistan is not capable of using direct international funds in an appropriate manner.
Meanwhile, Transparency International released a report Thursday noting that high levels of corruption among Afghan defence organisations – especially the Ministry of Defence – posed grave risks in the supplies and procurement sector after the withdrawal of international troops.
SIGAR officials said that Kabul had failed to correctly use billions of dollars from the US and other international donors and warned that the pledge of future billions is likely to be similarly squandered.
"The Afghan government does not appear to have the capacity to manage the $8 billion pledge by the international community and direct assistance, and that funds provided through direct assistance are typically subject to less oversight than funds provided through projects implemented by US and other donor government agencies," said John Sopko, SIGAR chief.
Afghanistan's Ministry of Interior rejected the statement saying the government was putting the funds to good use, while the Independent Joint Anti-Corruption Monitoring and Evaluation Committee said it supported direct fund assistance.
"If they [the donors] say they will provide the funds indirectly... You know, the brokers in between will take the money meant for Afghanistan. In the first step, they will take for themselves 20 to 22 percent for their administrative expenses, which is taken from Afghanistan's rights," committee head Mohammad Yaseen Osmani said.
"I support a way in which funds are provided directly, however it should be under principals and inspections," he added.
Nevertheless, SIGAR pointed out that with the withdrawal of international forces and non-government organisations by the end of 2014, Afghan development programmes over the next two years were essential.
The Transparency International study released Thursday revealed the corruption among defence organisations is primarily clear in the areas of employment, supplies, and promotions.
This level of corruption in this sector is ultimately putting lives at risk, the group said.
"Corruption in defence is dangerous, divisive, and wasteful, and the cost is paid by citizens, soldiers, and governments. Our study suggests that the corruption problem is pervasive in defence around the world, with a significant proportion of this spending at risk. Even worse, high levels of defence corruption lead to impunity and public mistrust," said Mark Pyman, Director of Transparency International UK's Defence and Security Programme.
"As the responsibility for defence purchase spending shifts from the Isaf coalition to the Ministry of Defence, the Afghan MOD spending will increase hugely; this will put much greater stress on their procurement system, with many more corruption opportunities," Pyman added.
The report suggested more should be done to strengthen the human, financial, and operational resources involved in Afghan defence procurement and the international community's have tougher policies for the implementation and monitoring of the sector.
Integrity Watch Afghanistan welcomed the report and said the devastating effects of corruption needed to be realised.
"Corruption in the Afghan defence force has devastating effects in the context of transition. It erodes the confidence of the Afghan citizens and political circles about the ability of the Afghan security forces to ensure future security of the country," said Yama Torabi, Executive Director of Integrity Watch Afghanistan.
"In addition, the waste in Afghan defence can potentially take away the resources from development and poverty reduction programmes," he added.
The Ministry of Defence declined to comment on Transparency International's report when requested by TOLOnews.
The reports come after the United Nations Assistance Mission to Afghanistan revealed last week that Afghan citizens paid an estimated US$4 billion in bribes to both the government and private sector in 2012.